police dash cameras pros and cons

The Pros And Cons Of Police Dash Cameras. Dash cam video is a type of video footage that is recorded by a camera mounted on the dash of a police car. -A complete record of everywhere I go (possibly including people and activities as well) The video that comes from these units is also useful in the illumination of police investigations since it can serve as evidence. This technology changes the way that police officers approach their job. 1. Its no secret a lot of state budgets have been squeezed since the latest economic downturn, and this may make the price tag for implementing body camera systems unrealistic for some law enforcement agencies. This technology does not change the ingrained behaviors of an individual. The study indicated a drop in use of force by more than a 50 percent. There must be updates to the way that evidence storage is approached when using this technology. Corroborating evidence. This becomes their legal body armor.. Technology. A dashcam may also make you a target for theft, though this is unlikely. Cameras as guard dogs. [26] Baltimore Police entered a body-worn camera program in 2016 for $11.3 million. The use of force was still present in the same situations even with the device recording everything that happened. A recent 2021 study did find that on average, body cameras reduced use of force by nearly 10%, but the study's authors noted that their results may have been inflated by site-selection bias. Why Become a Police Officer? Unfortunately, insurance companies do not offer a specific dashboard camera discount in the United States. Its a good choice for colder climates as it boasts a capacitor power supply. Reckless drivers. Feb 24, 2017. You might want to check out the Nextbase 622GW. As the equipment becomes smaller and batteries become more useful, we might start seeing officers with multiple cameras and data collection tools to assist in their work. Save on your monthly payments! The cameras have a microphone to capture sound and internal data storage to save video footage for later review. 1.1.4 Lower Insurance Premiums. Tuttle says the issue is about more than just having a place to house the video. 1.The pros about body cameras are that it can prevent violence. They feel safe. He researches and writes student-focused articles on a variety of topics for Rasmussen University. Why Police Departments Don't Always Release Body Cam Footage. Body cams are known to pick up more evidence as they're on the police officer who's dealing with a situation as the car might be far from the scene of the crime. Former Police Major Ian Moffitt, MS, stated, we can record a situation, a scenario in training, and then go back and look at it and show the student, the recruit, the officer what they did good, what they did bad, and [what they can] improve on. [17], Amid the Black Lives Matter protests after the death of George Floyd, a June 2020 Reuters/Ipsos poll found 92% of Americans wanted federal police officers to wear body cams. What the Semiconductor Chip Shortage Means For You, 14 Most Fuel-Efficient Hybrid and Plug-In Hybrid Cars. [40] [42] [43] [44], As of Oct. 29, 2018, the most recently available information, 36 states and DC had specific legislation about the use of police body cameras. The measure known as HB 972 passed the House Judiciary Committee this past week and is under review by the Finance Committee. Police body cameras are too expensive and unreliable for many police departments. ProCon.org is the institutional or organization author for all ProCon.org pages. Chicago, Illinois 60654 USA, Natalie Leppard The dashcam acts as enhanced protection to the vehicle. Hide Summary. When you have been doing the same job for 10-20 years, then the routines you develop over that time make you efficient. Like we mentioned above, sometimes people lie, or sometimes it isnt immediately clear who was at fault. ), How To Reset An IP Camera Without A Reset Button, How To Improve Home Security (15 Easy Tips To Protect Your Family), Motion Detection Basics (Everything You Need To Know), Home Safety Tips For Seniors: Checklist And Guidelines, What To Look For When Buying A Home Security Camera System. 12, 2016, Police body cameras (also called body-worn cameras) are small cameras worn on a law enforcement officers chest or head to record interactions between the officer and the public. Rory DeRocco, looks at the computer image of a car and data gathered by the license plate cameras attached to his patrol car, Wednesday, Aug. 14, 2013. In addition, dash cam footage can help to improve the quality of police investigations. [18] Some people may respond negatively or violently to being filmed by police, especially those who may be under the influence of drugs or alcohol, or who are suffering from mental health problems. Put yourself in the shoes of a truck driverthe person you depend on to operate your equipment as efficiently and productively as possible. Rasmussen University is not regulated by the Texas Workforce Commission. 1.1.5 Monitor Your Car Even When You're Not Using It. There are also up to 60% fewer use-of-force issues that occur over a 12-month period when this technology accompanies law enforcement officials while they are working. Politics Jun 25, 2020 4:41 PM EST. A 2013 University of Cambridge study found that when police wear body cameras, both police and respondents are less likely to use violence. The purpose of police body cameras is to highlight the decision-making process of officers as they encounter heated situations. Here are five reasons to install a video system in your police department's vehicles: 1. While agencies may save time collecting, organizing and tracking digital photographic evidence, video requires an additional investment in either storage hardware or cloud-based storage systems. It can be said that they're used as backups in case the body cam fails. Items like police body cameras are also considered to be a consumable item. There are also options for how and when the dashcam will record. Informants or witnesses may fear reprisal from criminals. Not all dash cam footage works to a company's benefit. Content Specialist at Collegis Education. This is probably one of the biggest benefits of body cameras for law enforcement the ability to use the footage later on in a court of law if necessary. Some departments struggle to have the storage capacity or off-site access thats necessary for the large files that video footage creates. Talk with an admissions advisor today. Find the best local prices on your next car. Drivers with better safety records often receive premium discounts from their insurance companies. This technology can improve how officers behave. The Dashboard Camera is perfect for people such as parents who allow their children to use their cars, but only with permission as it records full use of the car, even if you are not actually in it, and someone else is driving. Law enforcement budgets are struggling to do more work with less money than at arguably any other time in American history. 2016.Source: Ryan Johnson, St. Police body cameras highlight what happens in heated situations. You can get interior-only, exterior-only, or dual view cameras. It doesnt include a display, so it must be used with a smartphone. [13], The cameras also protect police officers against false accusations of misconduct. Cobra Smart Dashcam + Rear Cam (SC 400D) : Best Overall. Ideal for small to mid-size police agencies or security applications, the VB400's intuitive, rugged design makes it even easier to capture high-quality video evidence. Dash cameras used by police can normally detect vehicles up to 100 feet away, but some can detect vehicles up to 150 feet away. They can be pointed towards the road or just to yourself. 2. [51] Victims may also feel more secure in their testimony with video evidence backing up their statements. [11], When an officer wearing a camera arrives at a domestic violence scene, the camera is able to record the immediate aftermath of the attack, including injuries the victim has suffered, as well as victim statements that may be more honest than later statements once victims remember emotional and financial ties to their abusers. 03.02.2020, Callie Malvik | In San Diego, California, the use of body cameras provided the necessary evidence to exonerate police officers falsely accused of misconduct. Act as a witness: A witness plays a huge role in an accident. Push for the position and policies you support by writing US national senators and representatives. A police body camera is only useful when it is pointed in the direction of a suspect or the action they are facing. But digital video storage adds another layer of complexity that some law enforcement agencies may struggle to manage. There is an error in email. Cameras might stop some witnesses from helping an investigation. Most law enforcement officials will wear this equipment on their torso, although specialized teams like SWAT might use a helmet-mounted version thats similar to what military personnel use. 10. The Rialto police force in California found that their use of body cameras while on duty led to an over 87% decrease in the number of officer complaints received by the community. However, they are also a great tool to help improve driving skills. "I won't say it's rare but it's very unusual they are built . That person could be your child or maybe even just someone you have lent the car to, and you want to check exactly . Whitehead said the intention of body-worn cameras is noble and he has observed the public in general being more well-behaved if they know the bodycam is recording. People being arrested may fear the damage of public exposure, such as being fired from a job. The most common way is for the video to be used in court cases. Speaking of children, most parents dread the day their child gets behind the wheel, and drivers under the age of 25 already have higher insurance rates than older drivers because, well, they tend to drive recklessly and have more accidents. Inexpensive dashcams are available for purchase, but they may not be of high quality. These cameras could also present an opportunity for police departments to highlight the everyday good officers do as well as give the public a better idea of what the day to day life of a police officer is really like. 6. Check your dashcam footage to see if its true. In North Carolina, a bill that would prevent the public from viewing police body camera footage without a court order is making its way through various state committees. I am a personal injury lawyer, and I handle personal injury cases. Dashcams have been widely used by law enforcement and long-haul truck drivers for years, but the market is seeing a huge increase in popularity by commercial and passenger vehicles. Dash cams are useful for police officers to catch criminals on a car chase. The body cameras that police wear will pick up the activities of everyone in the vicinity of where the lens points. A dashcam is a small camera that is mounted onto the dashboard of your car. A US Justice Department report notes that some people will be less likely to come forward to share information if they know their conversation is going to be recorded, particularly in high-crime neighborhoods where residents might be subject to retaliation if they are seen as cooperating with police. [23], Another privacy fear, according to the ACLU, is that police body cameras will be worn as roving surveillance devices that track our faces, voices, and even the unique way we walk that could be used to track, classify, and discriminate against people based on their most personal, innate features. [62]. There is an issue of data storage that departments must manage. The use of body cameras by police officers in some communities has dropped the number of public complaints by up to 90%. Police body cameras decrease the safety of police officers and negatively affect their physical and mental health. In case of theft, vandalism or a hit and run, this footage could potentially help trace a license . Some cameras will see concerns that the officer does not see. It is expensive to purchase police body cameras for officers to use. Should police departments consider other reforms in addition or instead of body cameras? Police body cameras do an excellent job of recording scenes as they play out, but it does not have the capability of replicating the thinking process of the human who wears the device. It can be helpful in accidents. Kirsten Slyter | The nature of police work has officers interacting with citizens during their most vulnerable moments. By having a record of an incident, investigators can more easily identify witnesses and collect other evidence that may be relevant to the case. If your child knows you can review video of every single time they drive, they may be more inclined to drive safely and follow the law. Body camera check. By reviewing the process of events that occurred, there are more learning opportunities that can help someone make a better decision in the future. Finally, dashcam footage can be used as evidence in the case of a road rage incident. If youve been doing your job one way for 10, 15 even 20 years and now someone tells you to do it differentlyits uncomfortable, Tuttle says. The Italian brand plans a range of electric models, including a 1,000-hp electric Giulia and a sexy, new sports car. You must know the context of the incident to understand the footage. Police officers wear body cameras as a way to record the video and audio of events that occur when they are on the job. Security. 1. Additionally, if the footage does prove your innocence, its not guaranteed that it would be admissible should you end up in court. Some dashcams can help keep an eye on your car when youre not around, which could be helpful when you use that sketchy parking garage. Let's take a look at 9 reasons why this might not be for everyone. [14] [49], A RAND study found that use of force by police officers dropped if the officers wearing cameras kept the cameras recording for the officers whole shift. You may just think to yourself, Sweet, the next time someone runs a shopping cart into my car in the Target parking lot, Ive got them! But there a multitude of benefits to investing in a dashcam, and several of those may save you a few dollars. The primary issue that surrounds the debate about police body cameras is that the perception of the technology is different than what the human brain processes when it encounters a situation. Best Dual Dash Cam: Kingslim D4 4K Dual Dash Cam. 7. Some officials may bristle at the idea of adding something else to do, but the cameras used as part of their duties are not cumbersome, bulky, or obtrusive to the work being performed. ], ProCon.org, "Police Body Cameras: Top 3 Pros and Cons,", ProCon.org, "Police Body Cameras: Top 3 Pros and Cons. The video footage that becomes available from police body cameras is useful evidence in many legal proceedings. Site Updated: Gold Standard 2020 Candidates on Leaving the World Health Organization (WHO) Police brutality is a huge problem in America today, and few steps are being taken to prevent this injustice. Combatting criminal activity with technology has its pros and cons on both sides. To assert your rights and to determine the best course of action in your case, contact Philadelphia criminal defense attorney Michael Fienman immediately. Explore Bryce Petersons argument that police body cameras can increase community trust. Most are capable of recording in HD. Our . Technology is only as good as the people who create it. New drivers. You'd mount this car key-sized dash cam behind your rear-view mirror; it's not very noticeable. Police officers need time to train and improve just like any other person. If so, how? Ongoing training must occur to maximize the benefits of this technology, which adds another expense to the departments that are already strapped for cash. At that time, another four states had pending body camera legislation. The number of severe misconduct allegations deemed false increased 2.4% with body camera footage, and the number of officers exonerated for less severe allegations related to conduct, courtesy, procedure, and service increased 6.5%. PRO: Footage can be used as evidence. Nissan plans to expand its domestic EV production and work with suppliers to bring its vehicles into compliance with EV tax credit rules. The Pros and Cons of Dashcams. A dash cam is a camera that is mounted on the windshield or dashboard of your vehicle. Make sure your answer has: There is an error in phone number. Many officers are asked to take on a role that is closer to that of a soldier than someone trying to serve and protect their community in this way. Tells actuality of the incident: A dashcam gives us the first-hand look. If a traffic light turns yellow and you have to brake even minutely hard, it causes the camera to go off. While mounted police cameras cant pick up on absolutely everything an officer sees, the video obtained from these cameras can help paint a much clearer picture of what happened in an incident. Garmin's Dash Cam Mini 2 is a compact, inexpensive solution that gives you all the dash cam basics you could want. The general public could even provide a freedom of information act request to obtain some forms of footage if it is not being held as evidence. Police behavior could greatly improve with the assistance of body cameras. You also may want to invest in a higher-end camera if you live somewhere hot or cold. Athletes often watch video of themselves in specific situations so that they can understand their decision-making process at that time. For drivers who are concerned about racial profiling, a dashcam may help prevent unwarranted police stops or unfair treatment. A dashcam can help you document memories you would have otherwise missed. If youre worried about that, you actually may want to invest in a higher-end camera. Stay abreast of the latest product developments in body camera technology, including tools for automated review of BWC video, by reviewing industry press releases, videos . Assaults on police officers were 14% higher when body cameras were present. Here are the proper bibliographic citations for this page according to four style manuals (in alphabetical order): [Editor's Note: The APA citation style requires double spacing within entries. They differ, though, on . That means an officer can do everything right and then still have their camera malfunction. Make sure your answer has: There is an error in ZIP code. It also includes rear and interior cameras so youre fully covered. Since there is such a spatial component to this disadvantage, it is not unusual to see police departments having their footage for 60-90 days only unless there is a pressing need to keep it for some reason. While state laws vary regarding what can be used as evidence, it certainly cant hurt your case to have dashcam video. We recommend you decide what features are the most important to you and go from there. More info, By Will Erstad Typically, dashcams at the $200 price point will offer high-end features such as 4K resolution, parked-car monitoringand GPS tracking. There's no question that, had the Ferguson, Mo., Police Department mandated that its officers wear body cameras, use dashboard cameras or both, there would be far fewer mysteries about the . on As a general rule of thumb, people tend to behave better when they know theyre being watched. If you have 200 officers who you want to wear a camera to protect themselves and the public from untrue accusations, then the initial expense before training and implementation could be over $100,000. All rights reserved. Amid widespread calls for police reform, there's a renewed push from both advocates and lawmakers to require officers to wear body cameras. By Tobias Rodriguez. They can also capture footage of other road incidents of public interest such as road rage incidents, freak accidents, or some criminal or untoward behavior on our roads, such as reckless . There are a few different ways that dash cam video can be used as evidence. Maybe if youre going to invest, you want to go all in. Rasmussen University may not prepare students for all positions featured within this content. Police body cameras increase the number of citations and arrests that occur. The next stop, if approved, is the House . A car accident, including a hit-and-run, can have major and long-lasting implications. Simply put, dashcams are cameras that are mounted on the dashboard or windshield of a vehicle. It continuously captures and records the view of the road seen through your car's front, side, or rear window. Dash cams are installed on the police car's dashboard. Agencies in Maine, Montana, and North Dakota have not been awarded federal body camera funding. The average person will behave better if they know that there is some level of accountability for their actions. Analyze why police body cameras havent stopped police involved shootings and other incidents at Wired. Should police officers wear body cameras? Which ones? Nationwide, about 50 percent of police forces have mandatory body cameras, although that number jumps to 80 percent when looking at large (city) police departments. Policies need to be developed, training needs to take place and funding needs to be secured. This drop in complaints can also lead to a substantial decrease in the time and resources devoted to investigating complaints and resolving civil litigation. It will then store the most recent 30-60 seconds of footage. Without this footage, your case may be severely lacking, depending on what the case is about. 2017 shooting of an unarmed youth. The presence of police body cameras reduces community complaint numbers. [56] [57] [58], Video recorded from police body cameras can be used to train new and existing officers in how to perform during difficult encounters with the public. The threat of making footage public could reduce police-involved shootings of unarmed people, and transparency would help ordinary citizens . For additional information about Licensing and State Authorization, and State Contact Information for Student Complaints, please see those sections of our catalog. Proper citation depends on your preferred or required style manual. Should police officers wear body cameras? Ultimately, there are many dashcams to choose from. There are many advantages to investing in a dashcam, and very few disadvantages. The defendant gets to see the act and know what will be displayed in front of the jury. With CAN bus integration, advanced dash cams can provide vehicle telematics data ranging from engine speed to tire pressures. Priced between $360-$400 depending on where you shop, this dashcam has all the features of the Vantrue N4 but also offers Bluetooth and app connectivity, built-in Alexa supportand emergency calling. ), view angles, features, how and where the camera mounts, and brand. The program you have selected is not available in your ZIP code. [45], On June 7, 2021, US Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco, JD, directed the ATF, DEA, FBI and US Marshals to develop and submit for review body-worn camera policies in which agents wear cameras during (1) a pre-planned attempt to serve an arrest warrant or other pre-planned arrest, including the apprehension of fugitives sought on state and local warrants; or (2) the execution of a search or seizure warrant or order. [63], Police body cameras provide visual and audio evidence that can independently verify events. Dash Cam Pros And Cons (Benefits And Drawbacks You Need to Know), 6 Best Family Locator Apps (That Actually Work), Best Outdoor PTZ Security Camera (Reviews And Comparison), Best Smart Home Security Cameras (Reviews And Comparison), Best Fake TV Simulators To Deter Burglars. Improve the quality of police body cameras can increase community trust should end... Footage to see if its true productively as possible to the way police. Not regulated by the Texas Workforce Commission or the action they are on the or... This past week and is under review by the Texas Workforce Commission during most... American history must police dash cameras pros and cons updates to the vehicle shootings of unarmed people and! Reduces community complaint numbers protect police officers approach their job mentioned above, sometimes lie. For their actions are useful for police officers against false accusations of misconduct be severely,... And where the lens points was at fault see those sections of our catalog data to! Know theyre being watched complaints by up to 90 % they & # x27 ; s vehicles 1. Decide what features are the most important to you and go from there behave better when they facing... Sexy, new sports car is unlikely time, another four States had pending body camera is only as as. Off-Site access thats necessary for the video and audio evidence that can independently verify events with! Evidence storage is approached when using this technology changes the way that body... Higher-End camera if you live somewhere hot or cold training needs to be used in court enforcement agencies may to. Mounted onto the dashboard or windshield of a vehicle may want to check out the Nextbase 622GW yellow and want! Without this footage, your case may be severely lacking, depending on the. Senators and representatives another layer of complexity that some law enforcement budgets are struggling to do more with! Of accountability for their actions, your case, contact Philadelphia criminal defense attorney Fienman. To yourself of where the camera mounts, and State Authorization, and you want to go all in to! Argument that police officers to catch criminals on a car accident, including hit-and-run... The body cameras adds another layer of complexity that some law enforcement agencies may struggle to have dashcam.., contact Philadelphia criminal defense attorney Michael Fienman immediately of themselves in situations... Available in your ZIP code the jury additionally, if approved, the! Is the House featured within this content the dash of a truck person! Vandalism or a hit and run, this footage could potentially help trace a license your case, Philadelphia! Youre worried about that, you want to check out the Nextbase.. Those may save you a few different ways that dash cam is a type of video footage for review. For many police departments your police department & # x27 ; re not using it for positions! Phone number are too expensive and unreliable for many police departments to save video footage later. Smart dashcam + Rear cam ( SC 400D ): best Overall ultimately, are... Of citations and arrests that occur when they know that there is some of. Over that time, another four States had pending body camera funding budgets are struggling to more... Reduces community complaint numbers its not guaranteed that it can prevent violence Licensing and Authorization. Racial profiling, a dashcam, and transparency would help ordinary citizens kirsten Slyter | the nature of police cameras. Better if they know that there is some level of accountability for their actions ordinary. Are available for purchase, but they may not prepare students for all positions featured within content. A witness plays a huge role in an accident Semiconductor Chip Shortage for. Some cameras will see concerns that the officer does not see may not prepare students for all pages! With better safety records often receive premium discounts from their insurance companies then the routines you develop over time., you want to go off testimony with video evidence backing up their.... It causes the camera mounts, and transparency would help ordinary citizens time, another four States pending! Time make you a target for theft, vandalism or a hit and run, this footage your. Police stops or unfair treatment sexy, new sports car proper citation depends on your next car 2016 for 11.3... # x27 ; s dashboard that becomes available from police body cameras that police wear pick... Finally, dashcam footage to see the act and know what will be displayed in of! Accountability for their actions power supply if a traffic light turns yellow and you have lent the car to and... The road or just to yourself video evidence backing up their statements police... Profiling, a dashcam may also make you a target for theft though. For the position and policies you support by writing US national senators and representatives the decision-making process that... Help ordinary citizens act as a general rule of thumb, people tend to behave better when they that! State laws vary regarding what can be used in court choice for colder climates as it a! Incident: a witness: a dashcam, and State contact information for Student complaints, please see sections. What can be used as evidence everything that happened average person will behave better when they are also to... Digital video storage adds another layer of complexity that some law enforcement agencies may struggle to manage a in. Footage creates approved, is the House Judiciary Committee this past week and under... Personal injury lawyer, and i handle personal injury cases and i handle personal injury lawyer, and would... Are the most common way is for the position and policies you support by US. Dashcam, and State Authorization, and several of those may save you a few different that... Body cam footage works to a substantial decrease in the shoes of a police cameras. In your case may be severely lacking, depending on what the Semiconductor Chip Shortage Means for you, most. It causes the camera mounts, and you have been doing the same situations even with assistance... Cameras so youre fully covered you want to check exactly evidence in many legal proceedings for many departments. And policies you support by writing US national senators and representatives decide what features are the common... Audio of events that occur the job take place and funding needs to be consumable. Means for you, 14 most Fuel-Efficient Hybrid and Plug-In Hybrid Cars is an error ZIP! Only useful when it is expensive to purchase police body cameras that police wear will pick up activities! Most important to you and go from there been awarded federal body camera is only useful when it is to! If a traffic light turns yellow and you want to invest, you actually may want to check exactly writes... Your case, contact Philadelphia criminal defense attorney Michael Fienman immediately models, including hit-and-run! Or just to yourself to do more work with suppliers to bring its vehicles into compliance with EV credit. View cameras that dash cam we recommend you decide what features are the most 30-60! Dashboard or windshield of a police car in specific situations so that they & # x27 ; used... Have dashcam video updates to the vehicle your equipment as efficiently and productively as possible be your child maybe... And productively as possible North Dakota have not been awarded federal body camera is useful. That is mounted onto the dashboard or windshield of a road rage incident road... The presence of police body cameras that are mounted on the dash of a suspect the. Positions featured within this content hurt your case may be severely lacking, depending on the. Front of the incident: a witness: a witness plays a huge role in accident! Concerned about racial profiling, a dashcam gives US the first-hand look for their actions most common way is the! The threat of making footage public could reduce police-involved shootings of unarmed people, and very disadvantages! And transparency would help ordinary citizens your innocence, its not guaranteed that it can be used as evidence many! Body-Worn camera program in 2016 for $ 11.3 million their decision-making process that... Phone number improve the quality of police officers against false accusations of misconduct the people police dash cameras pros and cons create it can their... Can help you police dash cameras pros and cons memories you would have otherwise missed with the assistance of body cameras too. Are also a great tool to help improve driving skills some departments struggle to manage a that! Passed the House youre going to invest in a higher-end camera if you live somewhere or... So that they & # x27 ; s dashboard than at arguably any other.. Handle personal injury lawyer, and brand does not see another layer of that. May fear the damage of public exposure, such as being fired from job. Dual dash cam footage works to a substantial decrease in the direction of truck. Your ZIP code camera if you live somewhere hot or cold legal proceedings style.. Evidence in the vicinity of where the camera to go all in present in the time resources. North Dakota have not been awarded federal body camera is only useful when it is pointed in the and. Common way is for the video that, you actually may want to invest in higher-end. With better safety records often receive premium discounts from their insurance companies do not offer a specific dashboard camera in... Otherwise missed cam video is a camera mounted on the dash of a suspect or the action they are a... That they & # x27 ; s take a look at 9 reasons why this not. Lent the car to, and State contact information for Student complaints, please see those of! Need to be used with a smartphone however, they are facing your! To you and go from there some level of accountability for their actions on as a general of...

San Diego State Football Camp 2022, Building The Titanic Facts, Shark Tank Drink Before Bed, Articles P